Starting your own broker-dealer (BD) or joining an established one can be a viable option for investment banking managing directors' large books of business. A primary motivation is the need for a more direct compensation structure, and a substantial degree of independence in one’s investment banking career. However, there are multiple major factors to consider when deciding between starting your own broker-dealer, or partnering with an established firm.
For the uninitiated, or if you’re reading this blog post because the title caught your eye: a broker-dealer is a financial services entity that buys and sells securities for its own account, or on behalf of its clients. Broker-dealers can act as both brokers or agents when executing orders on behalf of clients, and as dealers or principals when trading for their own account. This blog post breaks down the costs and benefits for an independent investment banker of starting your own broker-dealer, and compares these to those associated with outsourcing to a third party broker-dealer.
Starting a broker-dealer from scratch means filing a New Membership Application with FINRA, meeting net capital requirements, building a written supervisory procedures manual, and standing up compliance infrastructure before accepting a single engagement. Most independent bankers who go through this process do it because they assume it is the only way to legally collect transaction-based compensation on M&A and capital raising deals.
It is not the only way. Bankers can also affiliate with an existing, FINRA-registered broker-dealer like Finalis and begin working deals under that firm’s registration, sometimes within days rather than the months a new broker-dealer application typically requires. The sections below walk through what building your own broker-dealer actually involves, so you can compare the two paths directly.
Should I start a broker-dealer?
To cut to the chase: it’s an expensive proposition, and is not a quick process by any means. As a BD, you become subject to numerous rules and regulations from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, and the investment banking industry’s regulator, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), as well as regulators in every single state in which your BD will operate (including any state that your transactions touch, such as the principal place of business of your clients and your clients’ counterparts).
How long does it take to start a broker-dealer firm?
Once you submit your application to FINRA, FINRA must review and process your application within 180 days. It will take a substantial amount of time to accumulate and organize all information required as part of the application process, which can take anywhere from 9 to 18 months. FINRA will typically make ongoing requests for documentation and engaging in constant back-and-forth communication.
What are the requirements for starting your own broker-dealer?
The most important step is to register with FINRA via the New Member Application (NMA) process, which typically takes from 3 to 6 months with many document requirements and an in-person interview. Next is to take the Series 24 exam, since a broker-dealer requires a supervisory principal. You will need to appoint a Chief Compliance Officer, a Finance Operations Principal, and another registered principal (FINRA requires two principals in a firm, with a principal waiver process a possibility). Registration in all states where you intend to conduct securities transactions is required, as well as joining the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). All of the firm’s principals will need to be properly licensed, with all required exams taken and passed; and the firm will need to have written supervisory procedures on all its lines of business (which will require in-depth review by FINRA). And these are all just for starters.
Affiliating With Finalis Instead of Building Your Own
Finalis is a FINRA-registered broker-dealer built for independent investment bankers, M&A advisors, and placement agents. Members affiliate under Finalis’ existing registration and compliance infrastructure rather than building their own from scratch, designed to keep more of your success fees in your pocket.
You keep your deal practice, your relationships, and your brand. Finalis provides the FINRA registration, supervisory oversight, and compliance support required to collect transaction-based compensation legally, along with access to Finalis’ network of affiliated Members and firms.
Most Members find switching to an existing broker-dealer to be way faster than building their own. In some cases, you can be registered in days, not the months a new broker-dealer application typically requires. Contact us to learn how we can help you.
How can Finalis help you?
Finalis provides bankers access to compliant, tech-driven workflows; with a focus on providing world-class regulatory compliance support and legal resources, in a 100% cloud-based technology platform. With Finalis, you can rest assured that you have a reliable partner who can help you navigate the complexities of the investment banking industry and ensure that you can launch and grow your investment banking business with confidence. Contact us to learn how we can help you.




